Published: 2011-09-30
ISBN:
ISSN: 1650-3686 (print), 1650-3740 (online)
The confederate form of its government and the cantonal structure of the Swiss state largely conditions Switzerland’s museum geography. Cultural affairs are not generally managed by the federal government but are traditionally the jurisdiction of the cantons; and all except a handful of Switzerland’s 949 museums are not national (Federal Department for the Interior; 2005: 3). The birth of Switzerland’s first national museum was long and arduous and great apprehension was repeatedly expressed at the idea of such an institution. For many Swiss; it represented an obvious contradiction to the state’s federal-national principal. In the years between the establishment of the first Helvetic Republic (1798-1803) up until the creation of the Swiss confederate state in 1848 and following; no national museums of any kind were founded. A material reason for this was that the creation of the Federal state was not accompanied by any massive movement of secularization; such as that which had; in France; transferred huge quantities of church possessions and artworks into the hands of the state. In Switzerland; the secularization of ecclesiastical treasures was a gradual process going back to the period of the Reformation and thus predating national concerns. This process had already given rise to many local and regional museum institutions; as a well-developed pre-national principal that boasted fine collections of international stature. Indeed; the project for a national museum presented an obvious difficulty as it implied choosing one place where the country’s national heritage would be presented and represented. However diplomatic difficulties were overturned by the need to stop the sale and export of Swiss antiquities abroad. Yet; since the establishment of the Landesmuseum; in Zurich in 1890; the national museum institution has; though somewhat half heartedly; tried to expand to provide more territorial representativity than the existence of one unique institution established in Zurich can offer. It has only; in the last two decades; come to include the museum of the Château de Prangins in French Switzerland and the Forum Schweizer Geschichte Schwyz; in the German speaking Alpine region (cf. Annex table). The Forum (1995) is; in a sense; the first museum to have been founded to celebrate an idea of the Swiss nation (the Landesmuseum was itself founded to deal with the exodus of Swiss material culture). Its foundation celebrates the 700th anniversary of the Swiss confederation.
In many traditional and high profile fields of collecting; such as the fine arts; especially contemporary art and foreign old masters; ethnography and classical antiquities; Switzerland’s largest and most significant museums are either municipal; cantonal or private institutions. The federal government generally has no or little involvement in the promotion of contemporary artistic expression. In terms of subject matter; Switzerland’s nationally owned museums deal mainly with traditional artistic practices or historical issues of national or local importance. Most authors underline the fact that the Swiss museum landscape is extremely varied and fragmented. The difficulty of obtaining a clear overview and statistical information concerning questions of financing and management of Swiss museums is a problem indicated by various sources (Brülisauer; Schüle; 2004). Yvette Jaggi; president of the Suisse federal cultural foundation; has commented on the absence of public debate concerning a federal cultural policy as a possible consequence of Switzerland’s plurilingual society; which; though source of cultural diversity and richness; also makes communication and exchange more difficult (Pro Helvetia; 2005: 8). The selection of museums chosen in the table below; and in the case studies; shows that Switzerland’s most important ‘national’ museums do not necessarily correspond with Switzerland’s most important museums; according to criteria of visitor numbers or general renown. In terms of art museums for example; and as included in the annex; the collections of Basel; Bern; Geneva or the Kunsthaus of Zurich are more renowned then those of the Landesmuseum. Furthermore; only two of the selected museums are directly run by the Federal state as part of the official network of Federal museums. Indeed; this selection is based on two principals allowing us to go beyond to the very strongly restricted Swiss national museum label (since 2010 it includes only 3 museums). The museums chosen are all mainly financed by the Federal state and their narrative is clearly of ‘national’ scope; in the Swiss context.
Brülisauer; J. and Schüle; B. (2004) Switzerland; European Group of Museum Statistics in Europe Online; available HTTP: http://www.egmus.eu/; (accessed 6 March 2010).
Brülisauer; J. (1998) ‘Der Verband der Museen der Schweiz: VMS = L’association des musées suisses: AMS’; Archäologie der Schweiz; 21: 48-49.
Federal Office of Culture (2009) Catalogue of the permanent exhibition in the National Museum Zurich; Collections Gallery; Swiss National Museum; Zurich: OFC.
Deuchler; F. (ed.) (1981) Museen der Schweiz; Zürich: Ex Libris.
Draeyer; H. (1999) Das Schweizerische Landesmuseum Zürich: Bau- und Entwicklungsgeschichte 1889-1998; Zürich: Schweizerisches Landesmuseum.
Federal Department of the Interior (2005) Bericht des Eidgenössisches Department des Innern über die Museums politik des Bundes; online; available HTTP: http://www.bak.admin.ch/themen/kulturpolitik/01544/01546/index.html?lang=de (accessed 4 March; 2010).
Forum der Schweizer Geschichte in Schwyz (2000) Schwyz: Aufstand der Dinge : Geschichten und Dinge porträtieren einen Kanton; Schwyz: Forum der Schweizer Geschichte.
Frauchiger; U. (1995) Entwurf Schweiz: Anstiftung zur kulturellen Rauflust; Zürich: Ammann.
Furger; A. (2000) ‘Das Schweizerische Landesmuseum auf dem Weg in 21. Jahrhundert’; Zeitschrift für Sxhweizerische Archäologie und Kunstgeschichte; 57: 95-104.
—— (1998a) Swiss National Museum; Zurich Prangins; Banque Paribas: Zurich.
—— (1998b) ‘Das Schweizerische Landesmuseum; die Archaologie und eine Projektidee’; Archäologie Der Schweiz; 21 (2): 56-58.
Furger; A. and Sieber; T. (2008) ‘Inhalte – Bauen – Zukunft. Perspektiven auf das Neue Landesmuseum in Zürich’; Museen neu denken: Perspektiven der Kulturvermittlung un Zielgruppenarbeit; H. John and A. Dauschek (ed.); Bielefeld: Transcript Verlag.
Gamboni; D. (1987) Kunstgeographie; Zurich: Disentis; Pro Helvetia.
Kaeser; M.-A. (2008) Visions d’une civilisation engloutie. La représentation des villages lacustres de 1854 à nos jours; Hauterive; Zürich: Laténium; Schweizerisches Landesmuseum.
—— (2006)‘Des fantasmes d’une Suisse insulaire : le mythe de la ‘civilisation lacustre’; Perspective. La Revue de l’INHA; 2: 178-187.
—— (2004) Les lacustres. Archéologie et mythe national; Lausanne: Presses polytechniques et universitaires romandes.
Jost; H. U. (1988) ‘Nation Politics; and Art’; From Liotard to Le Corbusier. 200 years of Swiss Painting; 1730-1930; Zurich: Coordinating Commission for the Presence of Switzerland Abroad.
Lafontant Vallotton; C. (2007) Entre le musée et le marché: Heinrich Angst; collectionneur; marchand et premier directeur du Musée national suisse; Bern: Peter Lang.
Lapaire; C. and Schärer M. (1984) Schweizer Museumsführer: mit Einschluss des Fürstentums Liechtenstein. Guide des musées suisses. Guida dei musei svizzeri; Bern: Verlag Paul Haupt.
Lapaire; C. (1991) Museum of Art and History; Geneva; Zurich: Banque Paribas.
Leimgruber; W. and Christen; G. (1992) Sonderfall? Die Schweiz zwischen Reduit und Europa; Zurich: Musée national suisse; Office fédéral de culture.
Mottaz Baran; A. (2006) Publikum und Museen in der Schweiz: emblematische Vorstellungen und soziales Ritual; Bern: Peter Lang.
Pro Helvetia (2005) De A comme art à T comme tradition. Glossaire de la politique culturelle en Suisse; Zurich: Pro Helvetia.
Rubli M. F. (1995) Berner Museen: Museen; Sammlungen; Kunsthäuser; botanische Gärten; Schlösser; Gedenkstätten; und ein Zoo: ein Überblick; Bern: Benteli Verlag.
Schärer; M. (1993) ‘Quelques réflexions d’ordre général et une expérience suisse’; Musées et recherche; acts of colloquium held in Paris from 29th of November to 1s t décembre; Dijon: OCIM; 261-265.
Schoulepnikoff; C. de (1986) ‘Le chateau de Prangins; siege romand du Musée national suisse’; Unsere Kunstdenkmaler; 37: 292-296.
Schwarz; D. W. H. (1948) Das Schweizerische Landesmuseum; 1898-1948; Kunst; Handwerk und eschichte; Festbuch zum 50. Jahrestag der Eröffnung; Zurich: Atlantis Verlag.
Schweizerisches Landesmuseum (1998) Der Erfindung der Schweiz 1848-1948: Bildentwürfe einer Nation; Zurich: Schweizerisches Landesmuseum; Chronos.
—— (1980) Schatzkammer der Schweiz: Kostbarkeiten des Schweizerischen Landesmuseums; Zurich: Artemis.
Sturzenegger; T. (1999) Der Grosse Streit. Wie das Landesmuseum nach Zürich kam; Zürich: Mitteilungen der Antiquarischen Gesellschaft in Zürich.
Weckerle; C. (2010) ‘Country profil; Switzerland’; Council of Europe/ERICarts; Compendium of Cultural Policies and Trends in Europe; 11th edition; online; available HTTP : http://www.culturalpolicies.net/web/countries.php?pcid=1460; (accessed 5 March; 2010).
Zollinger; H. (ed.) (1996) Wieviel Kultur braucht der Mensch?: eine kritische Auseinandersetzung mit der Kulturnation Schweiz; Zurich: Schulthess.
Websites
The Latenium in Neuchâtel http://www.latenium.ch/#latenium1?id=1
Swiss Alpine Museum http://www.alpinesmuseum.ch/index.php?article_id=5&clang=2
