Published: 2011-11-22
ISBN: 978-91-7519-993-1
ISSN: 1650-3686 (print), 1650-3740 (online)
This paper examines a current trend within museum studies to conceptualise the contemporary museum as democratic; open; and working in partnership with its community; which is seen as a fundamental change from museums at some point in the past; when they were didactic and produced or encouraged a passive audience. This trend; it maintains; is not just produced by museums needing to fit into various agendas for social inclusivity; but also by some of the most important texts in museum history; which look at the ways in which various forms of agency worked to deny agency to the public. It argues that such a view radically understates the forms of agency available to ‘outsiders’ to museums in the past; and that as a corollary; analyses of the contemporary museum need to be wary of seeing shared agency as already achieved. By exploring the forces which work to distribute agency widely inside and beyond the museum; alongside those which worked to centralise agency in the institution of the museum and its curators; we can gain a much fuller understanding of museums past and present.
Alberti; S J M M; (2007); ‘The Museum Affect: Visiting Collections of Anatomy and Natural History’; in Science in the Marketplace: Nineteenth-Century Sites and Experiences (ed. Fyfe and Lightman); University of Chicago Press; Chicago.
––––; (2009); Nature and Culture: Objects; Disciplines and the Manchester Museum; Manchester University Press; Manchester.
Bennett; T; (1995); The Birth of the Museum: History; Theory; Politics; Routledge; London and New York.
Black; G; (2007); ‘Review: The Responsive Museum’; Museum & Society 5:2 (available online at http://www.le.ac.uk/ms/m&s/Issue%2014/reviews.pdf; accessed 27.5.11).
Carnegie; E; (2006); ‘“It wasn’t all bad”: representations of working-class cultures within
ocial history museums and their impact on audiences’; Museum & Society 4:2 (available online at http://www.le.ac.uk/ms/m&s/issue%2011/carnegie.pdf; accessed 27.5.11).
Forgan; S; (1998); ‘Bricks and bones: architecture and science in Victorian Britain’; in The Architecture of Science (ed. P Galison and E Thompson) MIT Press; Cambridge Massachussetts.
Gosden; C and Larson; F; (2007); Knowing Things: Exploring the Collections at the Pitt Rivers Museum1884–1945; Oxford University Press; Oxford.
Hill; K; (2005); Culture and Class in English Public Museums; 1850–1914; Ashgate; Aldershot.
––––; (2011); ‘Introduction: Whose Objects? Identity; Otherness and Materiality in the Display of the British Past c.1850-1950’; Museum History Journal 4:2; July.
Hooper-Greenhill; E; (1992); Museums and the Shaping of Knowledge; Routledge; London. IVR; n.d.; ‘Volunteers in museums: key findings and issues from the literature’; (available online at http://www.baringfoundation.org.uk/litreview.pdf; accessed 27.5.11).
Lang; Reeve; and Woollard (ed.) (2006); The Responsive Museum: Working with Audiences in the Twenty-First Century; Ashgate; Aldershot.
Larson; F; (2009); An Infinity of Things: How Sir Henry Wellcome Collected the World; Oxford University Press; Oxford.
MacLeod; S; (2005); Rethinking Museum Architecture: towards a site-specific history of production and use; in Reshaping Museum Space: Architecture; Design; Exhibitions (ed S MacLeod); Routledge; London; 9–25.
MacLeod; S; (2012); ‘Significant lives: telling stories of museum architecture’; in Museums and Biographies: Stories; Objects; Identities; (ed. K Hill) Boydell and Brewer; Woodbridge.
Pearce; S; (1990); ‘Objects as meaning; or narrating the past’; in Objects of Knowledge (ed. S Pearce); Athlone Press; London.
Ross; M; (2004); ‘Interpreting the New Museology’; Museum and Society 2:2 (available online at http://www.le.ac.uk/ms/m&s/Issue%205/ross.pdf; accessed 27.5.11).
Sandino; L; (2012) ‘A Curatocracy: Who and What Is a V&A Curator?’; in Museums and Biographies: Stories; Objects; Identities; (ed K Hill) Boydell and Brewer; Woodbridge.
Teather; J L; (1990). ‘The Museum Keepers: the Museums Association and the growth of Museum Professionalism’; Museum Management and Curatorship; 9: 1; 25–41.
Yanni; C; (1999); Nature’s Museums; Victorian Science and the Architecture of Display; Athlone Press; London.
