Conference article

Autonomy and Care in Medicine

Show more +

Published: 2013-01-28


ISSN: 1650-3686 (print), 1650-3740 (online)


This paper argues that the core principle of bioethics; autonomy; is rooted both in the 20th century history of the development of new medical technologies as in political liberalism transferred to medical practices; rendering the medical decision-making of patients a centerpiece of medical interventions. The paper shows how the ambiguity in the interpretation of autonomy reflects the ambivalence of bioethics towards making normative claims on the moral agents insofar as these go beyond the respect for a patient’s autonomy. In the second part; the paper analyzes the alternative approach of care ethics; which intends to emphasize both the vulnerability and dependency of the patient and the medical professions’ responsibility to care for the patient. However; neither ‘autonomy’ nor ‘care’ ethics approaches can address the social and institutional mediations of today’s health care ethics; the paper therefore concludes with a proposal to embrace a critical social-ethical approach to bioethics that is based on the tradition of human rights.


Bioethics; autonomy; care; political liberalism; responsibility; human rights


Beauchamp T. L. and Childress J. F. (2008) Principles of biomedical ethics; sixth edition. Oxford University Press; Oxford ; New York.

Burchell G.; Gordon; Colin; Miller; Peter (1991) The Foucault Effect. Studies in Governmentality. Chicago University Press; Chicago.

Butler J. (1997) The psychic life of power : theories in subjection. Stanford University Press; Stanford; Calif.

Clement G. (1996) Care; autonomy; and justice : feminism and the ethic of care. Westview Press; Boulder; Colo.

Conrad P. (2005) The shifting engines of medicine. Journal of Health and Social Behavior 4/6: 3-14.

Conrad P. (2008) The medicalization of society. On the transformation of human conditions into treatable disorders. Johns Hopkins University Press; Baltimore.

Conradi E. (2001) Take Care. Grundlagen einer Ethik der Achtsamkeit. Campus; Frankfurt a.M.

Devaney S. A.; Palomaki; Glenn E.; Scott; Joan A.; Diana W. Bianchi; (2011) Noninvasive Fetal Sex Determination Using Cell-Free Fetal DNA. A Systematic Review and Metaanalysis.

JAMA : the journal of the American Medical Association 306/6: 627-636.

Dickenson D. (1997) Property;Women and Politics. Subjects or Objects? Cambridge University Press; Cambridge.

Dickenson D. (2009) Body Shopping: The Economy Fuelled by Flesh and Blood oneworld; London.

Dodds S. (2007) Depending on Care: recognition of vulnearbility and the social contribution of care provision. Bioethics 21/9: 500-510.

Donchin A.; Purdy; Laura M. (1999) Embodying bioethics: recent feminist advances. Rowman & Littlefield Publishers; Lanham.

Durante C. (2009) Bioethics in a Pluralistic Society: Bioethical Methodology in Lieu of Moral Diversity. Med Health Care and Philosophy 12/35: 35-47.

Engelhardt H. T. (1986) The foundations of bioethics. Oxford University Press; New York.

Forst R. (2007) Das Recht auf Rechtfertigung. Elemente einer konstruktivistischen Theorie der Gerechtigkeit. suhrkamp; Frankfurt.

Gadamer H. G. (1996) The enigma of health (orig.:Über die Verborgenheit der Gesundheit 1993). Stanford University Press; Stanford.

Haker H. (2001) Compassion als Weltprogramm des Christentums - Eine ethische Auseinandersetzung mit Johann Baptist Metz. Concilium 4: 436-450.

Haker H. (2008) On the Limits of Liberal Bioethics. In: Düwell M.; Rehmann-Sutter; Christoph; Mieth; Dietmar (ed) The Contingent Nature of Life. Springer; Berlin et al.

Haker H. (2009) Gerechtigkeit und globale Armut – Neuere Ansätze zur Ökonomie und Ethik. In: Mieth D. (ed) Solidarität und Gerechtigkeit. Die Gesellschaft von Morgen gestalten. Stuttgarter Bibelwerk; Stuttgart.

Held V. (1995) Justice and care : essential readings in feminist ethics. Westview Press; Boulder; Colo.

Honneth A.; Butler; Judith; Geuss; Raymond; LearJonathan; Jay; Martin (2008) Reification: A new look at a new idea. Oxford University Press; Oxford.

Honneth A. (2011) Das Recht der Freiheit. Grundriss einer demokratischen Sittlichkeit. suhrkamp; Frankfurt.

Jonsen A. R. (1998) The birth of bioethics. Oxford University Press; New York.

Kittay E. F. and Feder E. K. (2002) The subject of care : feminist perspectives on dependency. Rowman & Littlefield Publishers; Lanham; Md.

Korsgaard C. (2009) Self-Constitution. Agency; Identity; and Integrity. Oxford University Press; Oxford.

Levinas E. (1998) Otherwise than being; or; Beyond essence. Duquesne University Press; Pittsburgh; Pa..

Levine C. (2001) Taking sides. Clashing views on controversial bioethical issues. McGraw Hill/Dushkin Pub. Group; Guilford; Conn.

Loe M. (2004) The rise of Viagra : how the little blue pill changed sex in America. New York University Press; New York.

Merleau-Ponty M. (1962) Phenomenology of perception. Humanities Press; New York.

Mackenzie C.; Stoljar; Natalie (2000) Relational autonomy : feminist perspectives on automony; agency; and the social self. Oxford University Press; New York.

O’Neill O. (2002) Autonomy and trust in bioethics. Cambridge University Press; Cambridge; New York.

Paley J. (2011) Commentary: Care tactics - arguments; absences and assumptions in relational ethics. Nursing Ethics 18/2: 243-254.

Pellegrino E. D.; Schulman; Adam; Merrill; Thomas W. (2009) Human Dignity and Bioethics. Essays commissioned by the President’s Council on Bioethics. Washington.

Shklar J. N. (1990) The faces of injustice. New Haven.

Singer P. (2011) Practical Ethics. Cambridge University Press; Cambridge.

Stirrat G. M.; Gill; R. (2005) Autonomy in medical ethics after O’Neill. Journal of Medical Ethics 31/127-130.

Tauber A. I. (2005) Patient autonomy and the ethics of responsibility. MIT Press; Cambridge; Mass.

Taylor C. (1992) Sources of the Self. The Making of Modern Identity.

Taylor C. (1992) The Ethics of Authenticity.

Vetlesen A. J. (2009) A philosophy of pain. Reaktion Books; London.

Citations in Crossref