Historiography as a Marker of Current Paradigms Comparing the Role of Complex Cultural Institutions: Negotiating Museums

Peter Aronsson
Linköping University, Sweden

Ladda ner artikel

Ingår i: Current Issues in European Cultural Studies; June 15-17; Norrköping; Sweden 2011

Linköping Electronic Conference Proceedings 62:18, s. 171-174

Visa mer +

Publicerad: 2011-11-22

ISBN: 978-91-7519-993-1

ISSN: 1650-3686 (tryckt), 1650-3740 (online)


Museums are the negotiated result of several logics: science and politics; universalism and particularism; difference and unity; change and continuity; materiality and narrative. At some contexts and moments in history they also become vital arenas for negotiating and consolidating new answers to these. In Europe an intensive demand for national museums followed the Napoleonic wars and the creation of nation states. Regional differences below and above the nation were rearranged for new spaces of knowledge and politics. In the Scandinavian context the cultural construction of Norden was vital to creating a peaceful environment in the midst of possible feelings of revenge and emancipation. In Europe trajectories of parallel interactions give witness to the long standing relevance of museums as components of what here will be theoretically constructed as a “cultural constitution” balancing nations need for continuity with handling of old and new challenged to the unity. The paper is based on research done in two projects and will also contribute to the discussion on the possibilities and limits to comparative method in culture studies.


Inga nyckelord är tillgängliga


Antal; Frederik (1966). “Reflections on classicism and romanticism”; Classicism and romanticism with other studies in art history; London : Routledge & K. Paul.

Bal; Mieke (1999). Quoting Caravaggio: Contemporary art; preposterous history; Chicago; Ill. : University of Chicago Press.

Clark; Kenneth (1950). Landscape painting; New York.

Coliva; Anna (2009). “Caravaggio chiama Bacon: La bellezza del dolore”; Caravaggio – Bacon; Roma; Galleria Borghese; 2 oktober 2009 – 24 januari 2010; Roma; 17-24.

Friedlaender; Walter (1955). Caravaggio studies; Princeton; N.J. : Princeton Univ. Press.

Gilbert; Creighton E. (1955). Caravaggio and his two cardinals; University Park; Pa. : Pennsylvania State University Press.

Gunn; Thom (1961). My sad captains and other poems; London: Faber.

Hibbard; Howard (1993). Caravaggio; (1983) London: Thames and Hudson.

Holly; Michael Ann (1996). Past looking: The rhetoric of the image and the historical imagination; Ithaca; N.Y. : Cornell University Press.

Holt; Elizabeth Gilmore; A documentary history of art; Garden City; N.Y. : Doubleyday; 1957-1966

Lambert; Gilles (2007). Caravaggio: A Genius beyond his time; Köln: Taschen.

Lewan; Bengt (1966). Drömmen om Italien: Italien i svenska resenärers skildringar från Atterbom till Snoilsky; diss.; Lund.

Pepper; D. Stephen (1994). Guido Reni: A complete catalogue of his works with an introductory text; Oxford: Phaidon.

Röttgen; Herwath (1974). Il Caravaggi; Ricerche e interpretazioni. Rom.

Spear; Richard E. (1982). Domenichino; New Haven: Yale University Press.

Citeringar i Crossref