Konferensartikel

National Museums in Slovakia: Nation Building Strategies in a Frequently Changing Environment

Visa mer +

Publicerad: 2011-09-30

ISBN:

ISSN: 1650-3686 (tryckt), 1650-3740 (online)

Abstract

The concept of Slovak nation building in the 19th and 20th centuries was influenced by various loyalties; pragmatic political decisions and changing ideologies. The crucial stages in the development of Slovak museums are closely connected with frequent changes affecting the Slovak territory and its inhabitants. Four such key periods can be defined:

  1. The Hungarian chapter (till 1918) - In 1895; resulting the activities of Slovak political leaders; the Museum of the Slovak Museum Society was established. It had a clear political and nation-building pattern opposing the official idea of state and national unity of the Hungarian Kingdom.
  2. First Czechoslovak republic (1918 - 1938) - Rivalry between two nation-building strategies. One promoted the existence of a Slovak nation; the other one was based on the idea of a Czechoslovak nation.
  3. Communist Czechoslovakia (1948-1989) - Museums were state controlled ideological institutions used for propaganda and indoctrination of the population. Historical exhibitions about national history had to legitimize the communist rule.
  4. Post-communist Slovak republic since 1993 - After the fall of communism; museums ceased to be strictly ideological or political institutions. They were adapting to the new conditions and searching for the new themes.

It is usual for multi-ethnic and multi-religious regions like Central Europe to provide competing identities. The Slovak case of nation making is characterized by ambiguity and ambivalence of national identity concepts. In the 19th and 20th centuries; Slovaks defined themselves in the process of confrontation with two national groups: Hungarian and Czech. This confrontation fundamentally influenced the development of Slovak museums aspiring for national status. Until 1938; two states Slovakia was a part of (the Kingdom of Hungary and the first Czechoslovak republic) did not officially acknowledge the existence of a separate Slovak nation. This caused lasting antagonism between nation-building strategies of Slovak museums and the official state ideas enforced by the ruling political elites.

Since 1948; the ideologists of the ruling Communist party considered the national questions only a tool for strengthening the official Marxist-Leninist ideology. Communists considered themselves the heirs of progressive national historical traditions; which should justify their rule. Slovak museums had to document the struggle for national independence but at the same time they had to promote the official state policy of Czechoslovak socialist patriotism. On the other side; this era brought massive growth; systematization and professionalization of the museum network and their exhibitions.

The fall of communism brought fundamental changes for the Slovak museums. Democratization brought considerable de-ideologization and de-politization of museums. New economic and political realities offered more flexibility; but also new (mainly financial) challenges. After the dissolution of Czechoslovakia; the Slovak National Museum became the central museum of the newly created state in need of a state-building narrative. However; Slovak museums demonstrated skepticism regarding the appeals for a more patriotic and primordial presentation of Slovak history. The Slovak National Museum laid aside the controversies accompanying the nationalization of Slovak narrative. At the same time; its representatives focused on uncomfortable themes of modern Slovak history. These topics; together with the reinterpretation of the past regarding the common Central European history and European project were reserved for the central museums. These were; in the first place; the Slovak National Museum and the Museum of Slovak National Uprising.

Nyckelord

Inga nyckelord är tillgängliga

Referenser

(1948) Czech and Slovak digital parliament repository; 7. zasadnutie SNR dna 18. decembra

1948. Online. Available HTTP: http://www.psp.cz/eknih/1948snr/stenprot/007schuz/s007002.htm (accessed 12 november 2010).

(3. 10. 2007) iŽurnál Ako od nás odchádzali kultúrne pamiatky. Online. Available HTTP: < http://www.izurnal.sk/index.php?Itemid=89&id=1181&option=com_content&task =view (accessed 5 november 2010).

(29. 1. 2010) Slovakia; Cultural profile Múzeá na Slovensku od roku 1989. Online. Available HTTP: < http://www.slovakia.culturalprofiles.net/?id=-13030 (accessed 22 november 2010).

(29. 1. 2010) Slovakia; Cultural profile Múzeá na Slovensku pred rokom 1989. Online. Available HTTP: http://www.slovakia.culturalprofiles.net/?id=-13029 (accessed 22 november 2010).

(29. 8. 2007) SME Fico: V médiách sú duchovní bezdomovci; Online. Available HTTP: http://www.sme.sk/c/3461961/fico-v-mediach-su-duchovni-bezdomovci.html (accessed 21 november 2010).

Babušíková; T. and Micev; S. (2007) Múzeum Slovenského národného povstania v Banskej Bystrici; Acta historica neosoliensia; 10: 389-404.

Bakke; E. (1999) Doomed to failure? The Czechoslovak nation project and the Slovak autonomist reaction 1919–1938; unpublished dissertation; University of Oslo.

—— (2004) The Making of Czechoslovakism in the First Czechoslovak Republic; in Schulze Wessel; M. (ed.); Loyalitäten in der Tschechoslowakischen Republik 1918–1938. Politische; nationale und kulturelle Zugehörigkeiten; München: R. Oldenbourg Verlag.

Daxner; Š. M. (1912) Slovenská otázka od konca 18. stoletia; Turciansky Sv. Martin: Kníhtlaciarsky úcastinársky spolok.

Gažo; J. (1975) Slovenské múzeá; Bratislava: Pallas.

Holcík; Š. et al. (1989) Slovenské národné múzeum Bratislava: Obzor.

Holec; R. (2009) Red Light District po slovensky; História; 9: 2.

Hollý; K. (2008a) Formovanie historickej pamäti o Andrejovi Kmetovi (1908-1914). Forum

Historiae. Online. Available HTTP: http://www.forumhistoriae.sk/FH1_2008/texty_1_2008/Holly.pdf (accessed 10 november 2010)

—— (2008b) Historická ideológia a slovenské národné hnutie na prelome 19. a 20. storocia; unpublished dissertation; Historical Institute of the Slovak Academy of Sciences.

—— (2009a) Negácia udalostnej histórie a historický optimizmus; in Historický casopis; 57: 243-269.

—— (2009b) Formovania historickej pamäti o Muzeálnej slovenskej spolocnosti do roku 1914 ako ideový konflikt „všeobecnej“ a „národnej“ vedy; in Z dejín vied a techniky na Slovensku; Bratislava: Spolocnost dejiny vedy a techniky.

—— (2011) Memorandum národa slovenského ako historiografický pramen; in Pekarovicová J.; Vojtech M.; Španová E. (eds); Studia Academica Slovaca 40. Prednášky XLVII. letnej školy slovenského jazyka a kultúry; Bratislava: Univerzita Komenského.

Holotík; L. (1953) K periodizácii slovenských dejín v období feudalizmu a kapitalizmu; in Historický casopis; 1: 42-73.

Hycko; J. et al. (1968) Slovenské národné múzeum; Bratislava: Vydavatelstvo slovenského fondu výtvarných umení.

Junek; M. (2004) Ceskoslovenské zemedelské muzeum v Bratislave. Nositel agrární muzejní tradice na Slovensku v letech první ceskoslovenské republiky; in Zemedelské školství; výzkum a osveta jako predpoklad hospodárského a sociálního rozvoje venkova v 19. a 20. Století; Uherské Hradište: Slovácke muzeum.

Jurkovic; M. (ed.) (1945) Slovenské múzeá. Ich vznik a prehlad zbierok; Martin: Sväz slovenských múzeí.

Kollár; Š. (2009) Návštevnost múzeí klesá – preco ?; Acta historica neosoliensia; 12: 396-410.

Kovác; D. (1997) Slováci & Cesi. Dejiny; Bratislava: Academic Electronic Press.

—— (2009) Formovanie národných identít v stredoeurópskom priestore; in Kiliánová; G.; Kowalská; E. and Krekovicová; E. (eds) My a tí druhí v modernej spolocnosti; Bratislava: Veda.

—— (2010) O historiografii a spolocnosti; Bratislava: Historický ústav SAV.

—— (2011) The Slovak political programme: from Hungarian patriotism to the Czecho- Slovak state; in Teich; M.; Kovác; D. and Brown; M. D. (eds) Slovakia in history; Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Lalkovic; M. (2003) Zväz ceskoslovenských múzeí a jeho prínos na formovaní slovenského múzejníctva; Zborník Slovenského národného múzea - Etnografia; 44: 91-114.

Lipták; L. (1987a) Múzeá a historiografia na Slovensku do roku 1918; Zborník Slovenského národného múzea - História; 27: 273-289.

—— (1987b) Historiografia a múzeá; Historický casopis; 35: 128-130.

—— (1990) Múzeá a historiografia na Slovensku po roku 1945; Zborník Slovenského národného múzea - História; 30: 245-258.

—— (1999) Storocie dlhšie ako sto rokov; Bratislava: Kalligram. Mannová; E. (ed.) (2000) A Concise History of Slovakia; Bratislava: Academic Electronic Press.

Maráky; P. (28. 6. 2008) Starý svet nie sú iba vitríny; SME. Online. Available HTTP: http://www.sme.sk/c/3950815/stary-svet-nie-su-iba-vitriny.html#ixzz17IkiZ91g (accessed 12 october 2010)

Mruškovic; Š.; Darulová; J. and Kollár; Š. (2005) Muzejníctvo; muzeológia a kultúrne dedicstvo; Banská Bystrica: Univerzita Mateja Bela.

Palárik; M. (2006) Príspevok k dejinám múzejných cinností na Slovensku; Studia Historica Nitriensia; 13: 251-260.

—— (2008) Múzejníctvo v Slovenskom štáte; Studia Historica Nitriensia; 14: 295-312.

Podoba; J. (2004) Národná identita a “Erinnerungspolitik” v slovenskej historiografií: Niekolko kritických postrehov od “susedov”; Historický casopis; 52: 262-268.

Prelovská; D. (2005) K problematike dokumentácie robotníckeho hnutia v 60-tych rokoch 20 storocia na stránkach casopisu Múzeum; Studia Historica Nitriensia; 12: 219-232.

Rychlík; J. (1998) Cesi a Slováci ve 20. století. Cesko-slovenské vztahy 1945-1992; Bratislava: Academic Electronic Press; Praha: Ústav T. G. Masaryka.

—— (2010) Zemedelská muzea v Ceskoslovensku; in Harna; J. and Rašticová; B. (eds) Agrární strana a její zájmové; družstevní a penežní organizace; Uherské Hradište: Slovácke muzeum.

Špét; J. (1988) Formování a rozvoj socialistického muzejnictví v CSR; Praha: Národní muzeum v Praze.

—— (2004) Prehled vývoje ceského muzejnictví I. (do roku 1945); Brno: Masarykova univerzita; Filozofická fakulta.

Vároš; M. (2006) Stratené slovenské poklady (1); Martin: Matica Slovenská.

—— (2007) Stratené slovenské poklady (2); Martin: Matica Slovenská.

Vlachovic; J (1979) Die Museen in der Entwicklung der Slowakischen Nationalkultur; Studia Historica Slovaca; 9: 187-233.

Vörös; L. (2009) Slováci: „Najvlasteneckejší Uhri“ alebo slobodný národ? Sociálne reprezentácie Slovákov v v madarskej tlaci v rokoch 1914-1918; in Drál; P. and Findor; A. (eds) Ako skúmat národ; Brno: Tribut EU.

—— (2010) Analytická historiografia versus národné dejiny; Pisa: Pisa University Press.

Citeringar i Crossref