Comparing National Museums: Methodological Reflections

Peter Aronsson
Tema Q (Culture Studies), Linköping University

Ladda ner artikelhttp://www.ep.liu.se/ecp_article/index.en.aspx?issue=030;article=001

Ingår i: Comparing: National Museums; Territories; Nation-Building and Change. NaMu IV; Linköping University; Norrköping; Sweden 18-20 February 2008

Linköping Electronic Conference Proceedings 30:1, s. 5-20

Visa mer +

Publicerad: 2008-05-20


ISSN: 1650-3686 (tryckt), 1650-3740 (online)


The article sets out to define the need for comparing national museums as complex cultural processes. To do this questions are developed that concern the workings of institutions as arenas for cultural policy and identity politics in relation to central fields of knowledge. Methodological considerations for designing a comparative project are presented; and finally four fields of comparative endeavours related to different sets of state-making processes are presented:

An all-encompassing European comparison (including colonial endeavours) on the path taken by various nations to establish the place of national museums and the role they play in the creation of community.

An in-depth study of how the national display in a selection of countries creates visions of cultural community. How do they deal with differences and belongings on a super-national level and how do they relate to regional differences?

From a citizens’ perspective the intentions of cultural policy or institutional ambitions might be of little importance. This part will simulate visitor experience of national narratives in a comparative selection of capitals from project one; in order to develop an understanding of how citizen experience relates to the more structural findings in the other sub-projects and hence map in what directions citizenship and community are moving through contemporary displays of national community.

The place of national museums in changing knowledge regimes.


Inga nyckelord är tillgängliga


Almond; Gabriel A. & Sidney Verba. The civic culture: political attitudes and democracy in five nations: an analytical study. (Boston;; 1965).

Alzén; Annika & Peter Aronsson; (red.). Demokratiskt kulturarv? Nationella institutioner; universella värden; lokala praktiker. (Norrköping: Linköpings universitet; 2006).

Aronsson; Peter. "Making National Museums: comparing institutional arrangements; narrative scope and cultural integration." NaMu; making national museums program; setting the frames; 26–28 February; Norrköping; Sweden [Elektronisk resurs] Linköping electronic conference proceedings (Online); 22; pp. 5–12. (Linköping: Linköping University Electronic Press; 2007).

Berger; Stefan. "National Historiographies in Transnational Perspective: Europe in the Nineteenth and Twentieth Centuries." Storia della Storiografia; no. 50 (2006): pp. 3–26.

Blickle; Peter; (ed.). Resistance; representation and community. (Oxford: Clarendon; 1997).

Bloch; Marc. "Toward a Comparative History of European Societies." Enterprise and Secular Change. (London; 1953).

Burke; Peter. The Demise of Royal Mythologies. (Oxford: Clarendon Press; 1998).

Coleman; Janet. "Preface." The individual in political theory and practice. ; xxv; 395 s. (Oxford: Clarendon; 1996).

Denk; Thomas 2002. Komparativ metod. Förståelse genom jämförelse. Studentlitteratur: Lund.

Déotte; Jean-Louise. "Rome; the Archetypal Museum; and the Louvre; the Negation of Division." Art in museums; New research in museum studies; 5; x; 292 s. (London: Athlone Press; 1995).

Dicks; Bella. Culture on display : the production of contemporary visitability. (Buckingham: Open University Press; 2003).

Duverger; Maurice. Party politics and pressure groups : A comparative introduction. (London; 1972).

Florida; Richard L. The flight of the creative class. The new global competition for talent. (New York: HarperBusiness; 2005).

Gustafsson; Harald. "Den gamla staten på nya äventyr. Synpunkter på nyare statsbildningsforskning." Scandia 72; no. 1 (2006): s. 93–117.

Inglehart; Ronald & Christian Welzel. Modernization; cultural change; and democracy: the human development sequence. (New York: Cambridge University Press; 2005).

Kidd; Colin. British identities before nationalism : ethnicity and nationhood in the Atlantic world; 1600–1800. (Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press; 1999).

Killerby; Paul. ""Trust Me; I’m From the Government": The Complex Relationship between Trust in Government and Quality of Governance." Cultural Policy Journal of New Zeeland; no. 25 (2005): pp. 1–15.

Kirshenblatt-Gimblett; Barbara. Destination culture. Tourism; museums; and heritage. (Berkeley: Univ. of California Press; 1998).

Knell; Simon J. 2007. Museums; fossils and the cultural revolution of science: m apping change in the politics of knowledge in early nineteenth-century museums; Museum revolutions: how museums and change and are changed. Simon J. Knell; Suzanne Macleod & Sheila E. R. Watson; (eds.); Routledge: London ; New York.

Kulturministerium; Danmarks. Kulturkanon. (Köbenhavn; 2006).

Landman; Todd 2007. Issues and methods in comparative politics : an introduction. Routledge: London.

Lowenthal; David. Possessed by the past: the heritage crusade and the spoils of history. (New York: Free Press; 1996).

Luke; Timothy W. Museum politics. Power plays at the exhibition. (Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press; 2002).

Löfgren; Orvar. On holiday: a history of vacationing. (Berkeley; Calif.: Univ. of California Press; 1999).

Mason; Rhiannon. Museums; Nations; Identities. Wales and its National Museums. (Cardiff: University of Wales Press; 2007).

Moore; Barrington. Social origins of dictatorship and democracy : lord and peasant in the making of the modern world. (Harmondsworth: Penguin; 1973).

Nair; Savithri Preetha 2007. Economic logic versus Enlightenment rationality: evolution of the museum-zoo-garden complex and the modern Indian city; 1843–1900; Museum revolutions: how museums and change and are changed. Simon J. Knell; Suzanne Macleod & Sheila E. R. Watson; (eds.); Routledge: London; New York.

Porciani; Ilaria. "Mapping Institutions; Comparing Historiographies: the Making of a European Atlas." Storia della Storiografia; no. 50 (2006): pp. 27–58.

Preziosi; Donald & Claire J. Farago; (Eds.). Grasping the world: the idea of the museum. (Aldershot: Ashgate; 2004).

Prösler; Martin. "Museums and globalization." Theorizing museums: representing identity and diversity in a changing world; 236. (Oxford: Blackwell; 1996).

Putnam; Robert D. Bowling alone: the collapse and revival of American community. (London: Simon & Schuster; 2001).

Putnam; Robert D.; Robert Leonardi & Raffaella Y. Nanetti. Making democracy work: civic traditions in modern Italy. (Princeton; N.J.: Princeton University Press; 1992).

Ragin; Charles C. 1987. The comparative method: moving beyond qualitative and quantitative strategies. University of California Press: Berkeley.

Rosenzweig; Roy & David P. Thelen. The presence of the past: popular uses of history in American life. (New York: Columbia Univ. Press; 1998).

Sandén; Annika. Stadsgemenskapens resurser och villkor. Samhällssyn och välfärdsstrategier i Linköping 1600–1620. (Linköping: Enheten för historia; ISAK; Univ.; 2005).

Skocpol; Theda & Margaret Somers. "The Uses of Comparativ History in Macrosocial Inquiry." Comparative studies in society and history (1980): pp. 174–97.

Szreter; Simon. "The state of social capital. Bringing back in power in politics and history." Theory and Society (2003).

Tilly; Charles. Big structures; large processes; huge comparisons. (New York: Russell Sage Foundation; 1984).

———. Democracy. (Cambridge; [England] ; New York: Cambridge University Press; 2007).

Tilly; Charles (ed.). The formation of national states in Western Europe. (Princeton; N.J.: Princeton U.P.; 1975).

Woolcock; Micheal. ”Social capital and economic development: Toward a theoretical synthesis and policy framework. ” Theory and Society 27 (1998).

Citeringar i Crossref